Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Honest Opinion Gang what do you think of these 25
1. Bruno Banducci
2. Dick Barwegen
3. Jim Benton
4. Gene Brito
5. Ed Budde
6. Lavern Dilweg
7. Ox Emerson
8. Randy Gradishar
9. Larry Grantham
10. Leon Gray
11. Cornell Green
12. Chuck Howley
13. Billy Howton
14. Harold Jackson
15. Verne Lewellen
16. Eddie Meador
17. John Niland
18. Jimmy Patton
19. Michael Dean Perry
20. Duane Putnam
21. Lou Rymkus
22. Del Shofner
23. Jim Ray Smith
24. Walt Sweeney
25. Al Wistert
1. Bruno Banducci
2. Dick Barwegen
3. Jim Benton
4. Gene Brito
5. Ed Budde
6. Lavern Dilweg
7. Ox Emerson
8. Randy Gradishar
9. Larry Grantham
10. Leon Gray
11. Cornell Green
12. Chuck Howley
13. Billy Howton
14. Harold Jackson
15. Verne Lewellen
16. Eddie Meador
17. John Niland
18. Jimmy Patton
19. Michael Dean Perry
20. Duane Putnam
21. Lou Rymkus
22. Del Shofner
23. Jim Ray Smith
24. Walt Sweeney
25. Al Wistert
-
- Posts: 155
- Joined: Fri Oct 24, 2014 11:32 pm
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
It's a very good list and certainly much better than that of the Senior Committee. What would you say if we dropped Benton, Budde and Jackson and replaced them with Dave Grayson, George Kunz and George Christensen?
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Updated List Thanks for the feedback Andy P.Andy Piascik wrote:It's a very good list and certainly much better than that of the Senior Committee. What would you say if we dropped Benton, Budde and Jackson and replaced them with Dave Grayson, George Kunz and George Christensen?
1. Bruno Banducci
2. Dick Barwegen
3. Gene Brito
4. George Christensen
5. Lavern Dilweg
6. Ox Emerson
7. Randy Gradishar
8. Larry Grantham
9. Leon Gray
10. Dave Grayson
11. Cornell Green
12. Chuck Howley
13. Billy Howton
14. George Kunz
15. Verne Lewellen
16. Eddie Meador
17. John Niland
18. Jimmy Patton
19. Michael Dean Perry
20. Duane Putnam
21. Lou Rymkus
22. Del Shofner
23. Jim Ray Smith
24. Walt Sweeney
25. Al Wistert
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
if anybody can think of three more names i could add to this list after the 3 seniors for 2023 get nominated elected Let me know
-
- Posts: 3205
- Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Though you dont support Isbell, Nobis or Craig making the HOF Andy, they along with Dilweg and Gradishar still represent five of the remaining eight members of the Blue Ribbon Panel's finalist list from 2020 and could get elected these next three years with hopefully, Lewellen, Emerson and Wistert(leftovers) making the semifinals in that timeframe. Hopefully, Howley and Meador could get elected ahead of Isbell, Nobis or Craig ... We will see
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
hypothetically brian what if one year they picked three super seniors what would you thinkBrian wolf wrote:Though you dont support Isbell, Nobis or Craig making the HOF Andy, they along with Dilweg and Gradishar still represent five of the remaining eight members of the Blue Ribbon Panel's finalist list from 2020 and could get elected these next three years with hopefully, Lewellen, Emerson and Wistert(leftovers) making the semifinals in that timeframe. Hopefully, Howley and Meador could get elected ahead of Isbell, Nobis or Craig ... We will see
-
- Posts: 3205
- Joined: Wed Nov 27, 2019 12:43 am
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
It would be great Robert but I am hopeful its at least one per year. That may be a miracle with these voters. I consider super-seniors players that mostly played before 1960, though players like Howton, Jim Ray Smith, Tunnell and others played further into the decade.
- TanksAndSpartans
- Posts: 1165
- Joined: Wed Nov 18, 2015 1:05 am
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
A super senior to me is a player who played before WWII. Every decade has snubs, but in my opinion, the '50s i.e. the golden era is pretty well represented in the HOF.
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Good point i can respect thatTanksAndSpartans wrote:A super senior to me is a player who played before WWII. Every decade has snubs, but in my opinion, the '50s i.e. the golden era is pretty well represented in the HOF.
Re: Andy Piascik's Take on Seniors
Hey Gang im curious i was doing some research and the name Glenn Presnell caught my eye and interest should i add him to my 25 seniors list for the class of 2024 appreciate the feed back