Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

Joe "Doc" Alexander was the cornerstone of the Rochester Jeffersons in the early 1920s. The team was pretty bad, but Alexander still managed to be named All-Pro in 1921 and '22. In all, he posted three All-Pro seasons ('21, '22 and '26 as a member of the New York Giants). He also helped the Giants win the NFL Championship in 1927.

3 seasons with postseason honors I think is a bit light, but I could be convinced. I'd like to see Gus Sonnenberg get in first since he's considered an all-decade player by some.