Professional Football Researchers Association Forum

If you could only place just ONE of the two in the HOVG, who would you choose?

Both made 5 Pro Bowls with Quick’s being all consecutive. Quick also had two first-team All Pros as opposed to Rison having just one, but Rison had three additional 2nd-team All-Pros. He's got a Ring as well!

Its close but I would take Rison. Had he just stayed in Atlanta, he may be in the HOF already but had bad stints in Cleveland, Jax and his last season in Oakland. Quick got hurt too much like DeSean Jackson but a better deep threat.
I have watched receivers for a long time and only three times saw Rison ever drop a ball. As quick as many players that have ever played ... Imagine him staying with GB in 1997 with Brooks and Freeman ? Keith Jackson should have stayed as well ...

As I posted on another thread, I believe Wes Chandler should be in the HOVG ...